- Beehiiv: 0% platform fee, ad network, advanced analytics. Best for serious / scaling newsletter creators.
- Substack: 10% platform fee but stronger network effects (Recommendations, Notes). Best for beginners.
- Tipping point: at 1,000+ paid subscribers, Beehiiv saves significant money. Below that, Substack's network is more valuable.
Beehiiv vs Substack — Detailed Comparison
| Feature | Beehiiv | Substack |
|---|---|---|
| Free tier | 2,500 subs | Unlimited |
| Paid plans | $42-$99/mo | $0/mo |
| Platform fee on paid subs | 0% | 10% |
| Network effects | Boosts (paid) | Recommendations (free) |
| Mobile app for readers | No | Yes |
| Mini-feed (Notes) | No | Yes (Substack Notes) |
| Analytics | Advanced | Basic |
| Custom domain | Free | $50/year |
| Built-in ad network | Yes | No |
| Referral program | Built-in | Limited |
| A/B testing | Yes | No |
| Best for | Scale, monetization | Beginners, network discovery |
Cost at Different Scales
Newsletter with 5,000 paid subscribers at $10/month:
| Platform | Monthly gross | Platform fees | Stripe | Net |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Beehiiv (Scale, $42/mo) | $50,000 | $42 + $0 cut | $1,500 | $48,458 |
| Substack | $50,000 | $5,000 (10%) | $1,500 | $43,500 |
Annual difference: ~$60K in Beehiiv's favor at this scale.
Beehiiv — Pros
- 0% revenue cut — saves significantly at scale.
- Built-in ad network — automated sponsorships.
- Advanced analytics — segments, attribution, A/B tests.
- Referral program — built-in growth lever.
- Free custom domain.
- UI / writer experience — modern, fast.
Beehiiv — Cons
- Monthly cost ($42-$99/mo) vs Substack's $0.
- Smaller user base — fewer cross-recommendations.
- No mobile app for readers.
- No mini-feed (Notes) — Substack has this.
- Boosts cost money (vs Substack's free Recommendations).
Substack — Pros
- Strong network effects — Recommendations drive ~30-40% of new subs.
- Substack Notes for cross-promotion.
- Mobile app for readers (massive engagement).
- Free for any size — no monthly cost.
- Easier UX for beginners.
Substack — Cons
- 10% revenue cut — adds up fast at scale.
- Custom domain costs $50/year.
- Limited analytics.
- No ad network beyond paid subs.
- Less customization.
When to Use Beehiiv
- Established with 1,000+ paid subscribers.
- Want to keep 100% of subscription revenue.
- Need advanced analytics + segmentation.
- Want built-in ad network monetization.
- A/B testing matters.
When to Use Substack
- Just starting out.
- Free is critical (no monthly cost).
- Network effects matter (cross-recommendations).
- Reader mobile app + Notes for engagement.
- Don't need advanced features.
Migration Strategy
Many start on Substack, migrate to Beehiiv at scale:
- Build to 500-1,000 paid subs on Substack.
- Run Beehiiv import tool (1-click).
- Notify subscribers via email.
- Maintain Substack as redirect to Beehiiv.
Expect 80-90% subscriber retention during migration.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is Beehiiv better than Substack?
For scale + monetization: yes (0% fee). For new creators + network effects: Substack is better.
Can I migrate from Substack to Beehiiv?
Yes — Beehiiv has 1-click Substack import. Posts + subscribers transfer.
How much does Beehiiv save vs Substack?
10% on paid subscriptions. At $50K/year revenue: $5,000 savings annually. At $500K: $50,000 savings.
Does Beehiiv have a reader mobile app?
Not as polished as Substack's. Beehiiv reader experience is web-based.
Should new creators start on Beehiiv?
Mixed. Substack's network effects help small creators. Beehiiv's free tier (2,500 subs) is enough to start with.
Key Takeaways
- Beehiiv: 0% fee, $42-$99/mo, ad network, advanced analytics.
- Substack: 10% fee, free, network effects, mobile app.
- Tipping point: 1,000+ paid subs favors Beehiiv.
- Easy migration via Beehiiv's Substack import tool.
- Best strategy: start Substack, migrate to Beehiiv at scale.
One link covers Beehiiv + Substack + everywhere
Add a UniLink URL to your social bios — features newsletter signup, sample posts. Free.